Help - Search - Members
Full Version: Sandboxie, what's your opinion
Piriform Forums > Computer Help and Discussion > Software
razz
I have never heard of this program till today and I checked on their website, it all sounds like great protection.

Is it worth downloading?

Can it coexist with ZoneAlarm and any A/V, anti-malware program?
Anthony A
QUOTE (razz @ Sep 21 2008, 05:21 PM) *
I have never heard of this program till today and I checked on their website, it all sounds like great protection.

Is it worth downloading?

Can it coexist with ZoneAlarm and any A/V, anti-malware program?


Yes to all your questions. Do a search on here there are many threads about it.
Tom AZ
I'm sure not a Sandboxie expert, but I use it 100% of the time with Firefox -- and love it. However, there are a few little setup things you'll need to do in order to capture any new bookmarks and any new legitimate downloads. Anthony can probably give you some help with this if you need it.
razz
Thank you for your thumbs up. I will give it a try.
YoKenny
I would like to try Sandboxie but I can't afford it being on a fixed pension and limited funds.

I use all the free applications that I can that prevent malware from infesting my system like a good anti virus application like Avira!, HOSTS file from hpHosts and MVPS, Windows Defender and WinPatrol.

So far I have been malware free since I started using the Internet about when it became available through a 1200BPS dial-up modem.

I warded off the infamous CWS plague, Mydoom, Sasser, Sobig and other prevalent infections unscathed using free applications and knowledge that I gained from the great community here on the Internet with one of them being GRC Discussion newsgroup http://www.grc.com/discussions.htm where I learned about what was good and what was bad.
Anthony A
QUOTE (YoKenny @ Sep 22 2008, 01:36 AM) *
I would like to try Sandboxie but I can't afford it being on a fixed pension and limited funds.

I use all the free applications that I can that prevent malware from infesting my system like a good anti virus application like Avira!, HOSTS file from hpHosts and MVPS, Windows Defender and WinPatrol.

So far I have been malware free since I started using the Internet about when it became available through a 1200BPS dial-up modem.

I warded off the infamous CWS plague, Mydoom, Sasser, Sobig and other prevalent infections unscathed using free applications and knowledge that I gained from the great community here on the Internet with one of them being GRC Discussion newsgroup http://www.grc.com/discussions.htm where I learned about what was good and what was bad.


Sandboxie has a free version. It has some limitations compared to the paid version but nothing I miss.
YoKenny
QUOTE (Anthony A @ Sep 22 2008, 01:38 AM) *
Sandboxie has a free version. It has some limitations compared to the paid version but nothing I miss.
I'm trying the free version from FileHippo now.
hazelnut

Kenny I also use the free version, and have for many months.

I could not imagine using my browser without it. Right-click, run sandboxed, has become second nature.

It's just another layer of protection, and one I would not be without.

Also when I close my browser, I empty the sandbox without thinking now. I know Humpty has set up more strictly than me, but I'm fine with mine as it is.

Also allows you to open an email you are not sure about and then delete the sandbox. But remember that email will now be gone, unless you have set sandboxie up to keep it.

A link here for anyone thinking about using it but wanting to know a bit more.

http://www.sandboxie.com/index.php?HelpTopics
craigathus
Hey razz wink.gif
I was using Sandboxie (free version) with IE7 & Outlook Express for months, and I wouldn't launch IE7 without it!
I'm now using it with Firefox & Thunderbird cool.gif
YoKenny
QUOTE (hazelnut @ Sep 22 2008, 03:04 AM) *
Kenny I also use the free version, and have for many months.

I could not imagine using my browser without it. Right-click, run sandboxed, has become second nature.

It's just another layer of protection, and one I would not be without.

Also when I close my browser, I empty the sandbox without thinking now. I know Humpty has set up more strictly than me, but I'm fine with mine as it is.

Also allows you to open an email you are not sure about and then delete the sandbox. But remember that email will now be gone, unless you have set sandboxie up to keep it.

A link here for anyone thinking about using it but wanting to know a bit more.

http://www.sandboxie.com/index.php?HelpTopics
Well this old dog just learned some new tricks Woof woof. laugh.gif
Humpty
My opinion is that Sandboxie is a great, if not one of the best security apps ever.

Less than half a meg download, around a meg installed, using minimal resources and exceptionally secure.

Sandboxie at default settings is highly secure and the below banter may seem a bit tedious but after using SB for a while and getting used to how it works it sorta becomes second nature.

Sandboxie - Getting Started

Sanboxie FAQ's

I have the registered version which allows me to create multiple sandboxes but I only usually use two.

The default sandbox is set so that only Firefox, Windows mail and WMP can run with only FF and Windows Mail being the only apps that can use internet resources.

In other words any sandbox can be set so only certain apps can run and only some or all of those apps can connect to the net.

I have a "Test" sandbox where I install all tpes of malware and rogue apps that I may want to check out as these simply cannot run in the default box as it's set for only certain apps.

Delete the contents of the Test sandbox and not a skerrick remains.

Control Your Sandbox
YoKenny
Well you have a convert here and now I have to learn a bit more about it.

It is running fine on the old PIII that I am using now with no apparent performance hit.
DennisD
BIG Returnil fan here, and always will be, but I think I may just dip my toe in the sand again. smile.gif
Anthony A
QUOTE (DennisD @ Sep 22 2008, 09:03 AM) *
BIG Returnil fan here, and always will be, but I think I may just dip my toe in the sand again. smile.gif


IMO Returnil and Sandboxie are very different. I would use Returnil for when I want to try out an app. Reboot and the app is gone. Sandboxie is better for browsing or running a specific program. You don't virtualize the whole system just the program and the files it needs to run and no reboot to get out of it.

I also had a system get destroyed with Returnil. Removed an older version of Returnil and installed a newer version and could not boot. Prior to that I was a big fan but now I don't use it.
razz
I use Incredimail as my email client, will Sandbox block any email coming and going?
Humpty
Anything not running in the sandbox will run as per normal.

I haven't run Incredimail but it should be able to run sanboxed without any problems.

Sandboxie will only block certain apps connecting to the net if configured to do so.

QUOTE (DennisD @ Sep 22 2008, 09:03 PM) *
BIG Returnil fan here, and always will be, but I think I may just dip my toe in the sand again. smile.gif

I use both along with Virtual Machines if and when the need arises.

There are horses for different courses with Sandboxie, Returnil and VM's excelling in their intended usage.
DennisD
Well, here I am, Sandboxed.

The reason I've decided to start using it is simply the ability to save stuff, like hopefully, bookmarks. I can save downloaded apps etc onto my partition, which is what I do. But bookmarks have to be cut and pasted into notepad if I'm using Returnil.

As you say Humpty, horses for courses. Returnil will always be the program of choice for trying new software, but for general browsing, it's now Sandboxie.

Am I right in thinking Sandboxie is now easier to use, or more streamlined if you like, than it was when it first came out?

Might just be my imagination. Or a senior moment. biggrin.gif
1984
im finally giving this a whirl as well....see if i like it.
YoKenny
QUOTE (1984 @ Sep 23 2008, 05:07 PM) *
im finally giving this a whirl as well....see if i like it.
I un-installed it as it is about as annoying as Vista's UAC.
Anthony A
QUOTE (YoKenny @ Sep 23 2008, 08:06 PM) *
I un-installed it as it is about as annoying as Vista's UAC.


How did you come to that conclusion?
YoKenny
QUOTE (Anthony A @ Sep 24 2008, 12:09 AM) *
How did you come to that conclusion?
Every time I tried to run an application it popped up a warning.

I guess I'm not patient enough to learn it.

I miss my ClicKey when running IE7 so I guess I'll have to figure out how to have it run automatically within Sandboxie.
YoKenny
Looks like I figured out how to add ClicKey to IE8 beta2 as it is working but I had to review the tutorial step buy step in order to get it into Sandboxie.
razz
QUOTE (Humpty @ Sep 22 2008, 09:28 AM) *
Anything not running in the sandbox will run as per normal.

I haven't run Incredimail but it should be able to run sanboxed without any problems.

Sandboxie will only block certain apps connecting to the net if configured to do so.


I want to run my email client within Sandbox as recommended for extra protection. All sounds great, except I use Incredimail and that needs a special setup which Sandbox supplies detailed instructions for. I followed the instructions very rigorously and then did the configuration test to insure no mail is lost when you delete contents in Sandbox. It was supposed to have worked but it didn't. I went through the procedure again (twice actually) and still no good. So I can't run Incredimail in Sandbox because I would lose my mail mad.gif My folders are in the default location etc.
It's very weird because according to Sanbox it should work. sad.gif

Any suggestion other than stop reading emails?
Humpty
You could post in Sandboxie's Forum where you should be able to get help.

No need to register as you can post as a guest.
razz
QUOTE (Humpty @ Sep 24 2008, 08:42 AM) *
You could post in Sandboxie's Forum where you should be able to get help.

No need to register as you can post as a guest.


Thank you Humpty, good idea.
Anthony A
QUOTE (YoKenny @ Sep 24 2008, 02:37 AM) *
Every time I tried to run an application it popped up a warning.

I guess I'm not patient enough to learn it.


What warning? If you use the free version you get a a pop up that tells you you are using the free version and it is limited. This happens only once per day the first time you launch Sandboxie.

It sounds like to me you have quick recovery set to notify you every time that you add a file to a recoverable folder. This can be turned off.

The way I have it set is that I use what ever program I am using as normal than when I close the program it automatically deletes the sandbox unless I have something in a recoverable folder than it warns me and asks if I want to recover it.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.